Chapter 4 - The Woman Upstairs
The second woman was Aunt Caroline.
Or at least that was what I thought for six terrifying hours.
Caroline was Evelyn’s younger sister.
She had been at the party.
She had disappeared upstairs twice.
And her voice carried the same soft Virginia vowels as the woman on Ben’s clip.
Detective Simmons refused guesses.
“We’ll identify through evidence.”
Good.
At noon, police obtained warrant.
The blue folder came out of Evelyn’s home.
So did a digital recorder.
A tablet.
Two old phones.
A stack of printed photographs.
Evelyn herself was not arrested that day.
She had given statement through attorney.
Her version:
She was concerned Sophie lived in “emotionally volatile environment.”
She had prepared notes in case Child Services contacted again.
She asked Sophie questions because she wanted ensure child could “speak honestly without Emily influencing her.”
She denied telling Sophie to lie.
She admitted taking her upstairs.
Admitted locking door.
“Privacy.”
Admitted grabbing Sophie’s arm.
“Because she tried to run downstairs before cleaning cut.”
Denied pushing.
Said Sophie tripped while pulling away.
Some of that might be true.
Then sunglasses.
Evelyn claimed Sophie asked because light hurt eye.
Sophie denied.
Then why tell her not to tell?
“She misunderstood.”
Everything became misunderstanding.
Then blue folder inventory.
Detective could not give us copies yet, but summarized.
Timeline labeled:
EMILY CONCERNS.
Dates.
Arguments.
Late school pickups.
One time I raised voice at Sophie in grocery store.
A photograph of Sophie with bruised shin after soccer.
Another with scraped elbow.
A screenshot of me holding wine at Christmas.
A copy of a prescription for anti-anxiety medication? Wait health info, not user sensitive? This is fictional, okay. But could feel. Maybe Emily had short-term sleep medication after her father's death. Evelyn included. Fine.
School attendance records.
Three tardies.
One absence.
Then draft petition.
Petition for temporary custody/guardianship based on parental instability.
Not filed.
Prepared by whom?
Unknown template.
Evelyn had written margin:
If Daniel won’t act, I will.
My mouth went dry.
Then Caroline called.
“I need to talk.”
I nearly refused.
Daniel said:
“Take it.”
I answered speaker with detective permission? Not necessary, but I could record? Better not secretly. I told her:
“Caroline, police are investigating.”
“I know.”
“Were you upstairs?”
“Yes.”
There.
Daniel stood.
“What did you do?”
“Nothing.”
“Your voice is on recording.”
Caroline cried.
“I went up because Evelyn asked me to bring tape.”
“For Sophie’s head?”
“No. Before.”
Silence.
“What tape?”
“Scotch tape. For papers.”
I frowned.
“Why?”
“She was taping questions to mirror so Sophie could read them.”
My stomach turned.
“Did you know?”
“I thought it was for school counselor.”
“What?”
“She said Sophie was nervous about a school meeting and wanted practice.”
“Did you hear what questions were?”
“Some.”
“And?”
Caroline cried harder.
“I told her not to pressure too hard.”
There.
The voice.
“Why didn’t you stop?”
“I didn’t understand.”
“You heard Sophie say it wasn’t true.”
Silence.
Then:
“Yes.”
My hands shook.
“You heard my daughter say your sister was asking her to repeat something untrue, and you walked downstairs?”
“I told Evelyn this was going too far.”
“Then what?”
“She told me mind my business.”
“And you did.”
Caroline sobbed.
“Yes.”
I ended call.
Daniel looked sick.
“Everybody knew pieces.”
Exactly.
No one knew enough alone.
But everyone chose comfort over confrontation.
Then Ben delivered full video to police.
Thirty seven seconds.
Camera pointed mostly toward hallway carpet because he was testing settings while walking upstairs.
Audio:
Evelyn:
Again.
Sophie:
Mom gets mad sometimes.
Evelyn:
Not sometimes. Say what we practiced.
Sophie:
But it isn’t true.
Evelyn:
If you want your father to understand what kind of mother Emily is, you’re going to say it exactly the way we practiced.
Caroline:
Ev, don’t pressure her too hard before interview.
Evelyn:
She has to be consistent.
Sophie:
I want Mommy.
Then clip ended.
Daniel listened once.
Then walked into hospital bathroom and vomited.
I sat beside Sophie’s bed.
My daughter was coloring with left hand because right wrist hurt from fall.
She looked at me.
“Dad sick?”
“Yes.”
“Because Grandma?”
“Yes.”
She nodded.
Then:
“Are you mad at him?”
Children see.
“Yes.”
“Are you leaving?”
That question.
I put crayon down.
“I don’t know what Dad and I are going to do yet.”
Her eyes widened.
“But whatever happens between adults, you are safe and loved.”
She started crying.
“Grandma said if you and Dad split, she gets me.”
My blood froze.
“What?”
“She said courts don’t like angry moms.”
I looked toward bathroom.
Daniel came out pale.
He heard.
Sophie continued:
“She said Dad would need help.”
Daniel lowered into chair.
“When did she say that?”
“Lots.”
“How many?”
“I don’t know.”
Then:
“She said when you move us away, she can stop you.”
Move us away.
There.
Our private conversation.
Three months earlier, I had received a job offer in Charlotte.
Daniel and I were considering it.
Only four people knew.
Me.
Daniel.
My sister.
And Evelyn.
I had asked Daniel not to tell her until decision.
He stared at floor.
I already knew.
“You told her.”
He whispered:
“Yes.”
“When?”
“The night you got offer.”
I stood.
Sophie looked scared.
I lowered voice.
“You promised me.”
“I know.”
“You promised because we knew she would make it about losing Sophie.”
“I thought if I told her early, she’d have time to adjust.”
Instead she had time to plan.
A Child Services report appeared weeks later.
The blue folder grew.
The coaching started.
The birthday party was not where Evelyn lost control.
It was where a plan built around keeping my daughter from moving away finally became visible.
Then Detective Simmons called.
“We identified the draft custody document’s author.”
I braced.
“Evelyn?”
“No.”
“It came from a law office.”
“Whose?”
A family law attorney named Martin Kline.
Daniel knew him.
His mother had consulted him two months before the anonymous Child Services report.
May you like
And the consultation notes included one sentence:
Client believes son may relocate with granddaughter and wants to establish record of maternal instability before relocation occurs.
