Chapter 4 - Patricia’s Version
Patricia retained a lawyer before sunrise.
That was her right.
Her statement to police stopped quickly after counsel arrived.
But the few things she said before invoking counsel mattered.
She admitted slapping me.
Not hard, she insisted.
She said Lily fell because I was “too exhausted to hold her properly.”
She denied giving Lily any medication.
She said the dropper in her toiletry bag was used for vitamins.
No infant vitamins matching it were found there.
Not proof.
Then the notebook.
Police did not show me immediately.
My lawyer, Rachel Donnelly, came to the hospital at 8 a.m. after Daniel called her. She handled family law and protective orders, while a separate criminal-victim advocate helped me navigate the investigation.
Rachel warned:
“Do not turn the notebook into your own investigation.”
“I won’t.”
“Do not post.”
“I won’t.”
“Do not message Patricia.”
“I won’t.”
Then:
“Do you want Daniel in the house?”
I looked through the PICU glass at Lily.
“I don’t know.”
That answer hurt.
Daniel heard later.
He did not argue.
Good.
Then the emergency protective order.
Patricia was barred from contacting me or approaching the hospital while the assault investigation continued.
She was also prohibited from entering our home after police finished executing the warrant because she was only a guest resident and Daniel, as co-owner, revoked his permission for her to remain. Our attorney still followed proper process regarding her belongings.
No dramatic curb eviction.
No broken locks.
Procedure.
Then Daniel voluntarily booked a hotel.
“I’ll give you space.”
I stared.
“You own half the house.”
“I know.”
“I’m not asking you to leave forever.”
“I know.”
Then:
“I should have seen this.”
“Yes.”
He accepted it.
No defense.
Then Lily’s confirmatory toxicology returned.
The sedative matched a medication Patricia had been prescribed.
Not merely the same category.
The same active substance.
Could someone else have obtained it?
Yes.
Could it have come from Patricia’s bottle?
Likely, but chemistry alone could not prove source.
Then her prescription count.
The pharmacy record showed a refill two weeks earlier.
The bottle contained fewer doses than expected if she took it exactly as prescribed.
Again, not proof.
People misplace pills.
Take variable doses.
Then the baby monitor cloud archive.
Detective Price asked Daniel and me not to access it until police preserved a forensic copy.
We agreed.
By afternoon, they had.
Hannah returned.
“There are clips we need you to see eventually.”
“What do they show?”
She looked at me.
“Patricia entering the nursery at night.”
“That’s normal. She was helping.”
“Yes.”
Then:
“In several clips, she carries a small medication bottle.”
My stomach dropped.
“Can you see what she does?”
“Not clearly enough in every clip.”
“Every?”
Hannah nodded.
“Four nights.”
Four.
The same four nights Lily had been unusually sleepy.
Then:
“One clip has audio.”
I could barely breathe.
“What does she say?”
Hannah looked at Daniel first.
Then me.
“She says, ‘Finally. Maybe now you’ll sleep like a normal baby.’”
No dosage.
No clear view of exactly what went into Lily’s mouth.
But enough to turn coincidence into pattern.
Then Daniel stood and walked to the wall.
He pressed both hands against it.
“My mother poisoned my daughter.”
Hannah corrected him.
“Your mother is under investigation for administering an unprescribed substance. We still prove each element.”
Daniel looked at her.
“Fine.”
Then he turned toward me.
“I let her do the night feeds.”
I stood.
“You did not know.”
“I ignored everything else.”
That was different.
True.
Then the notebook became available through the case.
Emily Safety Log.
Date after date.
Emily cried for forty minutes.
Emily forgot to sterilize one bottle.
Emily slept past alarm.
Emily took medication.
Emily raised voice when Patricia corrected swaddle.
Emily refused help.
Some were true.
Most lacked context.
Then several entries were false.
Emily missed 2 a.m. feeding.
I had not.
Patricia had volunteered to take it.
Emily left Lily unattended for twenty minutes.
I had been showering while Daniel was in the room.
Emily gave Lily unknown medication.
Never happened.
Then one entry:
If Daniel does not act soon, I may have to.
My skin went cold.
Below it:
Talk to Steven about emergency custody options.
Steven was Daniel’s cousin.
An attorney.
Daniel called him immediately.
Steven sounded horrified.
“Yes, Aunt Patricia asked me general questions.”
“What questions?”
“What happens if a new mother is unsafe. Whether a father can seek temporary exclusive custody.”
“Did she say Emily abused Lily?”
“No.”
“Drugs?”
“She implied medication misuse.”
My body went cold.
“Did you give her legal advice?”
“General information. I told her Daniel would need his own lawyer and evidence. I never agreed to file anything.”
Good.
No secret case.
No filed custody petition.
Just groundwork.
Patricia had been preparing a narrative in which I was the danger.
May you like
And the most horrifying part was beginning to emerge.
Some of the symptoms she recorded as proof I was failing may have been symptoms she helped create.
